Expert View: Earnings May Not Recover Anytime Soon; Green Shoots Emerging in IT, Says Pramod Gubbi of Marcellus
Expert Pramod Gubbi View: The Indian stock market has been riding a wave of uncertainty, with headwinds posing challenges for investors. Pramod Gubbi, co-founder of Marcellus Investment Managers, shares his expert insights on the current state of the market, the risks involved, and potential opportunities.
Market Outlook: Volatility to Persist
According to Gubbi, the Indian stock market is facing multiple challenges at the moment. Despite a recent decline, valuations remain elevated, making it difficult to predict a strong bounce in the near term.
Key factors contributing to the market decline include:
- Disappointing earnings growth: Many companies have failed to meet expectations, leading to negative sentiment.
- Foreign Institutional Investor (FII) Selling: The strengthening of the US dollar has triggered relentless selling by FIIs, leading to liquidity outflows.
- Domestic Flow Dependence: While domestic investments have been a strong pillar of support, a loss of patience among retail investors could result in significant sell-offs, particularly in small and mid-cap stocks.
“If the US dollar tops out, we might see some reversal in FII flows. However, if domestic flows weaken, small and mid-caps could be at significant risk,” Gubbi cautioned.
Key Risks to Watch Out For
Gubbi highlights three major risks that could impact market performance in the coming months:
- Earnings Growth vs. Valuations: Lofty valuations require strong earnings growth, but many companies are underperforming.
- US Dollar Strength: A strong dollar could continue to drive FII outflows, pressuring market liquidity.
- Retail Investor Sentiment: If domestic investors lose confidence, the market could see further declines, especially in smaller stocks.
Q3 Earnings: A Mixed Bag
The recently concluded Q3 earnings season showed some improvement compared to the last two quarters. Government capital expenditure (capex) made a comeback, helping economic recovery to some extent. However, certain sectors continued to struggle:
- Disappointments: Consumer staples, auto, and building materials sectors failed to meet expectations.
- Positive Surprises: Specialty chemicals showed strong recovery, indicating resilience in niche segments.
Despite marginal improvement, earnings have not kept up with the high valuations, leading to continued market concerns.
Investment Strategy: Quality Over Momentum
With market momentum fading, Gubbi advises investors to focus on quality stocks rather than chasing undervalued stocks or momentum trades.
“Investors should emphasize companies with strong balance sheets, clean accounting, solid governance, and sustainable competitive advantages,” he recommended.
Indian Economy: The Road Ahead
While India’s long-term macroeconomic fundamentals remain robust, there are signs of a cyclical slowdown. Key concerns include:
- Slowing public capex: Government spending has softened, affecting economic growth.
- Leveraged households: Rising household debt has dampened middle-class consumption.
- External pressures: A strong US dollar and global liquidity tightening are adding to economic stress.
On the positive side, rural demand is improving, and budgetary support for middle-class consumption could spur economic recovery in the coming quarters. However, Gubbi warns that a full-fledged recovery may take at least two more quarters.
Banking Sector: A Bright Spot
Among the different market sectors, banking appears to be one of the few offering reasonable valuations.
- Asset quality has improved, reducing non-performing assets (NPAs).
- Margins are strong, but credit growth remains a challenge.
- If the RBI injects more liquidity, credit growth could pick up, further supporting the sector.
Overall, banking remains a promising sector with relatively attractive valuations compared to other segments of the market.
Power Sector: Overvaluation Concerns
The power sector has seen extreme optimism, leading to high valuations. However, expectations of rapid growth seem overstated.
“Despite recent corrections, valuations remain elevated, suggesting the sector could face more downside risks,” Gubbi warned.
Green Shoots in IT Sector
One of the few bright spots in the market is the IT sector. Gubbi sees early signs of recovery, particularly in discretionary spending from US banks, which are key clients for Indian IT firms.
Additionally, the growing adoption of Generative AI (GenAI), driven by technologies like DeepSeek, could accelerate demand for IT services.
However, he cautions that current valuations have already factored in much of this optimism, making selective investment crucial.
Conclusion: Cautious Optimism with Selective Investing
The Indian stock market remains in a fragile state, with elevated valuations, sluggish earnings growth, and external pressures weighing on investor sentiment.
While challenges persist, certain sectors like banking and IT show promise. Investors are advised to focus on high-quality companies with strong fundamentals rather than chasing short-term market trends.
With uncertainty looming, patience and a disciplined approach to investing will be key in navigating the evolving market landscape.
Key Financial Ratios & Market Indicators
| Metric | Value/Commentary |
|---|---|
| Nifty 50 Decline | 11% from peak |
| FII Net Outflows | High due to USD strength |
| Retail Investor Sentiment | At risk if market remains volatile |
| Sector Performance | IT – Recovering, Banking – Attractive, Power – Overvalued |
| Earnings Growth | Below expectations |
| Public Capex | Recovering in Q3 but still slow |
| Domestic Liquidity | Dependent on RBI actions |
By keeping an eye on these factors, investors can make informed decisions and navigate market uncertainties effectively.
For more market insights, follow our blog.
Stay tuned for more updates and insights on the stock market! For more insights on investing in the Indian stock market, check out resource like ET, NSE India.
Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investors should conduct thorough research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions.